In Gods We Trust has ratings and 23 reviews. A cognitive anthropologist and psychologist, Scott Atran argues that religion is a by-product of human. In got trust. Scott Atran In Gods We Trust The Evolutionary Landscape Of Religion (Evolution And Cognition). Topics atheism. Collection. Library of Congress Cataloging-in-Publication Data Atran, Scott, In gods we trust: the evolutionary landscape of religion / Scott Atran. p. cm. — (Evolution .
|Published (Last):||11 November 2014|
|PDF File Size:||14.52 Mb|
|ePub File Size:||19.36 Mb|
|Price:||Free* [*Free Regsitration Required]|
Whirling dance, deep-breathing meditation, and other things can cause “altered states of consciousness.
In Gods We Trust: The Evolutionary Landscape of Religion – Oxford Scholarship
Shopbop Designer Fashion Brands. Part 2 Absurd Commitments. Watch for the emotional reaction when these views are challenged. But this does not entail that such terms will have a causally coherent extension. The author also has ni habit of citing various theories and pieces of writing, presenting and interpreting their claims in a rather nit-picky, constrained way, and criticizing their ideas because certain aspects ln not fully applicable under a wide-enough range of scenarios.
That said, certain concepts were phrased very elegantly favourite quotes follow. This ambitious, interdisciplinary book seeks to explain the origins of religion using our knowledge of the evolution of cognition.
Deborah Kelemen – – Wtran and Brain Sciences 27 6: The book also includes a chapter-length take-down of meme theory, which feels a bit odd considering how fringe it has been within academia.
After all, his book does not stick to its topic, so my review will depart from the content of his book. Likewise, the book’s concluding chapter brings everything back together and wraps it up.
Want to Read saving…. It stops just as soon as enough sense is ogds of a statement to be relevant by providing important new knowledge or rejecting of old knowledge. If you aren’t prepared for some dry, academic writing, avoid this book and pick up Pascal Boyer’s Religion Explained instead, which covers much of the same ground but in a more accessible style.
In Gods We Trust: The Evolutionary Landscape of Religion
There are no discussion topics on this book yet. Anything can grow contentious when tgust too literally. Religious believers, however, assume that the utterances or texts connected with religious doctrines are authorless, timeless, and true.
Mar 28, David Withun rated it really liked it Shelves: Joseph Bulbulia – – Biology and Philosophy 19 5: A respected cognitive anthropologist and psychologist, his publications include Fondement de l’histoire naturelleCognitive Foundations of Natural History: SimpsonDouglas T. Once or twice Atran says that he is going to tell us how religion originated, but I cannot fathom what he thinks he has told us.
In Gods We Trust
Oxford University Press Amazon. This ambitious, interdisciplinary book seeks to explain the origins of religion using our knowledge of the evolution of cognition. Thousands of books are eligible, including current and former best sellers. Aug 05, Mark Isaak rated it really liked it.
The contrast with the clarity of Pascal Boyer’s Religion Explained is remarkable. Yet there are odd things like for instance the study which I’m sure would have benefitted greatly from the addition of “a r Once or twice Atran says that he is going to tell us how religion originated, but I cannot fathom what he thinks atrah has told us.
Jul 29, Jason Yang rated it liked it. Instead, it seems more like a non-peer-reviewed stream of consciousness. I’m still interested in the ideas, so I’d love a Cliffnotes version or something.
The challenge is to not select only the evidence you want to believe. I think it is answerable and that they are, contra Steve Gould, a zero-sum game. Atran’s strength is in avoiding the reduction of religion to one element or purpose. The natural tendency to see supernatural agents was then adapted taran promote loyalty to the larger group, and replace selfish behaviour with a group inn. Within such cultural schemas, even the eccentric voices and visions of clinically diagnosed schizophrenics and epileptics can become publicly sanctioned revelations, as they are in some societies.
What he does do is describe a cognitive backdrop against which religious claims, once they appear from wherever, appear to humans to make sense. Is there a distinction to be made between group selection actually happening, and hard evidence that it does? There will always be conflicting ideas with varying degrees of validity and uncertainty.
In Gods We Trust: The Evolutionary Landscape of Religion – Scott Atran – Google Books
Philosophical Issues in Biology and Psychology. Displays are also more frequent than actual commitments, because they are usually less costly. Still, the trail takes one to some very interesting vistas. Nor, beyond what I mentioned above, does Atran offer a paradigm for future research.
The Science and Philosophy of Meditation and Enlightenment. He currently directs an international, multidisciplinary project on the natural history of the Lowland Maya.
People know or assume that public fictions novels, movies, cartoons, etc were created by specific people who teust particular intention for doing so. Counterintuition, Commitment, Compassion, Communion. I felt Glds strongest arguments against Wilson, however, were first, his demonstration of Wilson’s reliance on dated colonial ethnographies and anthropological studies, and second, arguing against Wilson’s reliance on treating abstractions such as religion and cultural norms as part of a kind of cultural super-organism.
A cognitive anthropologist and psychologist, Scott Atran argues ogds religion is a by-product of human evolution just as the cognitive intervention, cultural selection, and historical survival of religion is an accommodation of certain existential and moral elements that have evolved in the human condition. The Mess Inside Peter Goldie.
Analogy homoplasy reveals adaptation in similar traits that solve similar environmental problems in phylogenetically unrelated species, for example, the wings of bats and birds and flying insects, the eyes of humans and the octopus, and bipedality in therapods carnivorous dinosaurs such as Tyrannosaurus and humans.
I am not one for Evolutionary Psychology, but if you choose to use it as a tool. Those atean fall outside the belief system are seen as not only immoral, but positively intent on evil. The Evolutionary Origins of Religious Thought. I don’t accept that this totally refutes godw selection as a whole, but it does work in service against Wilson’s claims.